The Bloody Truth About Email Marketing

Email Critic | Rants and Raves of an Email Marketing Agency

home
bloggers
hall of fame
hall of shame
resources
contact

You Moved? I Never Knew You Were Here!

How important is your subject line?

Take a look at the email screenshot below. Let me know if you see the potential confusion that I see.

Business Email Marketing Samples

On the whole, this is a pretty solid email from LegalZoom. It’s a very simple offer, quick and to the point. It contains solid use of preheader text, whitelisting requests, header images, headlines, and content. What’s not to like?

The subject line. Specifically, the first two words of the subject line: “We’ve Moved!”

Should I classify this as an “Oops” or am I missing a Vandals song reference in the title? If it’s not a Vandals reference, then it has to be a mistake given that there is no reference to moving anywhere in the content of the message.

Perhaps a better subject line could have been: “Free Joe Friday! Get Free Legal Advice Every Friday.”

The moral of this story: The subject line is the second thing your recipients look at beyond who the email is from. A misleading subject line can destroy response metrics in a heartbeat.

About the Author: Scott Cohen is Vice President of Managed Services at Inbox Group. He also writes on email marketing, fatherhood, sports, and politics on ScottWritesEverything.com.

7 Comments

What not to do: 1 indispensable tip email marketers can learn from old direct marketing pros

The old pros had it completely wrong.

 

Direct mailers of the past would accept as gospel that you needed a full color envelope with “URGENT” emblazoned across the front, view windows, and other gimmicks to get folks to open and read their mail. The flashier the better! Do whatever you can to stand out. That will get your letter opened and read, right?

 

Wrong.

 

What they forgot was that people sorted their mail over the garbage can. Anything that resembled a “pitch” or “sales material” would be gleefully destroyed with extreme prejudice (see: above).

 

So what’s the point? They put all their time and effort into selling to these folks but. . .

 

People don’t want to be sold to.

Fun Story: One guy I know hated commercial mail so much, he’d go out of his way to open it, tear the offer into teeny-tiny little pieces before shoving it into the return envelope and TAPING it closed (yes, on all the edges, so they couldn’t open it). He would get some strange satisfaction out of harassing these companies that tried to sell him things.

 

The only thing that glitter and fanciness would accomplish is their letter immediately being identified as garbage. On the other hand when the direct mailers figured out that mailing their offers in a PLAIN envelope (no graphics, no windows, nothing), with a REAL stamp (no bulk rate penny pinching), and with a personal, engaging, thoughtful letter inside. . . all of a sudden they saw their response rates TAKE OFF. Go figure.

 

So how does this lesson translate into email marketing?

 

Here’s how.

 

Forget (or at least, focus LESS on) graphics and spend more time on your copy.

 

When an average person gets a commercial email what do they do? IF they open it (and that’s a BIG ‘if’), they SCAN it quickly, decide in 2 seconds whether it’s worth a 3rd second (it’s usually not) and mercilessly delete it. What does the average person do when they receive a personal email with no graphics or fancy type?

 

They read it.

 

Imagine that. . .They don’t begin by rushing to the end to see what is wanted from them, they simply begin reading. If your letter is written well enough (ie: the subject line compels them to open, the 1st sentence makes them read the 2nd, the 2nd the 3rd, etc.) you can just about sell anything to anyone.

 

If you’re trying to sell something via email and writing genuinely thoughtful copy specifically tailored for your audience isn’t your #1 focus (it almost never is) you’re doing it wrong.

 

So wise guy, what’s the lesson?

 

Here it is…

 

In email marketing: Copy > Everything Else.

 

This wonderful content was provided by email marketing consultant and resident email critic, Evan Diaz. You can e-stalk him via twitter @evandiaz
4 Comments

6 Interactive Marketing Email Ideas

There’s a reason brilliant email marketing isn’t all that common. It’s difficult.

You know you’re supposed to send value, not just offers. And you know you should engage your audience, not just blather about what’s new with you.

But some days, you can beat your brains out and still not come up with fresh, catchy ideas. So you throw your hands up with an, “I don’t know. Let’s just send a coupon again.”

If that’s you, you may just need some inspiration. Here’s a collection of brilliant emails that, without pushing offers, entertain subscribers and get responses.

Getting the Vote

Baskin-Robbins asks subscribers to vote for the the ice cream flavor they’d like to see brought back.

First of all, this brings traffic to Baskin-Robbins’ site. Plus, it makes readers feel like a valued part of the BR community. And if they vote for the winning flavor, they’ll feel a sense of ownership when they see it in stores – both very good reasons for them to talk the ice cream chain up to their friends.

Now fill in the blank: “I can ask fans of (your brand name) to vote on ______.”

Videos on View

If a picture is worth 1,000 words, how many words is a video worth? How about 5 videos?

Bombay Sapphire created a documentary to promote luxury products like their gin. They sent fans 5 chapters of it and simply asked them to watch.

The idea is that the education and entertainment viewers got from the videos would lead them to appreciate Bombay more, and that brand loyalty will sway them the next time they buy gin.

Now fill in the blank: “I can create a video about ____ to educate my subscribers.”

The Scoop on Poop

Yes, really. Luvs designed an iPhone game for their customers. Dirty diapers are just so much more enjoyable when you’re flinging them at pirates instead of having them flung at you by a 2-year old…

Not only will this create the need for reciprocity (link or address), but players will see Luvs branding every time they play.

Now fill in the blank: “My subscribers might have fun with a game about ______. How can I create one?”

Arts & Crafts Time

Home Made Simple put together a few craft ideas for kids and invited their subscribers to take advantage of them.

By facilitating fun family time, the brand earns the appreciation of parents while getting a new generation on board with their brand’s values. And it’s all free – again, encouraging brand loyalty.

Now fill in the blank: “Subscribers to (your brand name)’s emails might enjoy an activity that ______.”

It’s All About Location

Dunkin’ Donuts obviously wants their subscribers to come in, buy drinks and claim the free donuts offered here. But notice, that’s not what their call to action says…

Readers who click through are taken to a store locater to find a DD in their neighborhood. This way, whether subscribers participate in National Donut Day or not, they have the store on their neighborhood mental map and can stop in whenever the urge strikes.

Now answer this question: “What kind of mental map do I want (your brand name) to show up on? How can I get it to show up there?”

A Very Nike Story

Nike+ asked their fans to join their anniversary party by sharing their own user experience on Facebook.

When customers talk about Nike+ in their own words, they’re labeling themselves as “a Nike person.” They’re also developing a sense of ownership of the brand, which means they’ll want to support it – and see others support it – in the future.

Now answer the question: “What kind of stories might (your brand name)’s customers want to share? Where can I display those stories? Should I respond to any of them?”

On Second Thought

Threadless, like Baskin’ Robbins, asked their subscribers to vote on products to be released. The difference is that here, voting comes as a secondary option to the offer.

Sometimes you just can’t skip a direct call to buy (maybe you have a new product you need to promote or a sales goal to meet). But it can help to give subscribers other options, in case they’d rather interact with you a different way.

Now fill in the blank: “I plan to send this offer soon: ___. A nice little second option for my readers might be ______.”

All Done?

Great! Now you’ve got 7 new ideas for fun, fascinating, loyalty-building emails.

Not only will many of them push traffic to your web site, but you can use them to build goodwill with your email community, which pays off in the long run: when you ask for a purchase, they’ll know you earned it.

And while we’re on the topic of goodwill, let’s try something here: if you’re up to it, share one of your new email plans with your fellow marketers below.

And if you remember after sending the email out, come back and post a link to your archived message!

About the Author: Amanda Gagnon writes, rants and raves about email marketing over at AWeber, and occasionally tweets about it @AmandaEGagnon.

3 Comments

10 Ways Email Marketing is Better Than Social Media

Social media presents a wealth of new opportunities for marketers. Many find it has a lot of value in their marketing mix. But when compared to email marketing, does social deliver?

Even with all the great options social marketing presents, email marketing still seems to have many advantages over social media.

Here’s a list of 10 ways email marketing is better than social media marketing:

1. Guaranteed Views
When you send an email to a valid address you know it’ll arrive in your recipients inbox and they’ll have to recognize the message. At worst they’ll delete it without an open, which still presents a branding opportunity. However, in social channels you never know if anyone is seeing your message. Studies have found that 71% of tweets are ignored and brands have limited ability to determine if their content is even showing up in the streams of their Facebook connections.

2. Longevity
Even though email does achieve most of its results within the first 24-48 hours, it can still reside in an inbox until someone has the time to taking action on the message. In social media, your followers can miss a post or tweet entirely, and the ones they see will only be available until their stream is filled with other content.

3. Environment
Email recipients go to their inbox expecting to receive messages from people and businesses from which they have provided consent. Social media channels can be cluttered with content, advertising, alerts/notices, and other things that compete for users attention. Because of this social users tend to scan and pick out content while email users move from message to message. Email is generally a better environment for getting recipients to recognize and pay attention to your marketing content.

4. No Message Length Limitations
By not having to limit a message to a set character length, email allows marketers to present a more comprehensive marketing offer, explain benefits, support it with additional information and provide a strong call to action. The length of the message is determined by the marketer and not the limitations of the channel.

5. More creativity
Email allows marketers to fully explore their creative side by incorporating text, graphics and in some cases, animation and video all in one message.

6. More Significant Relationship
Those that opt-in to email lists are raising their hand saying they want to receive your marketing content. In social media, those that subscribe, like or follow your brand may be doing so for reasons beyond marketing, such as the opportunity for engagement or to see what others are saying. And filling out an opt-in form is usually a more considered decision than a one-click “like” or “follow”.

7. Personalization
Email content can be personalized with data or content specific to the recipient. Messages can even be customized based on purchase behavior, previous activity or many other variables. Personalization in social media is non-existant. Until social publishing tools can provide an automated process for creating personalized content, email will continue to trump social marketing in the ability to create personalized marketing messages.

8. Segmentation
Providing targeted, relevant marketing content almost always guarantees better results. Being able to segment your email list and use that data to provide a more targeted communication is a huge advantage of email over social.

9. Tracking / Reporting
Email offers the ability to track renders (opens), clicks, forwards, conversions, bouncebacks and much more. The reporting that you receive from an email campaign can provide a very accurate picture as to how recipients received your message, whether or not they found it interesting, whether or not they took action and if they completed the action. From a marketing standpoint, email reporting is superior to the metrics you receive from most social channels.

10. Higher Chance of Conversion
If your goal is getting someone to take action on your message, the ability to create a visually compelling message with a full marketing offer that is personalized and targeted to the recipient and has a higher likelihood of being seen should almost always lead to a higher conversion rate. And for most campaigns, that’s the main objective.

What other ways do you find email to be a better marketing channel than social?  Does social have any advantages over email?

About the Author: Adam Holden-Bache is CEO at Mass Transmit,  and purveyor of Email Transmit and Approved Emailer!

1 Comment

Email Marketing to Cats

Your customers aren’t always who you think they are. And they don’t automatically love you and approve of everything you do. In fact, they are much more like cats than dogs in the way they regard you…and me. I wrote on this some time ago in the ClickMail blog, and it was such a hit, I thought it worth reiterating here.

Whether you’re a dog person or a cat person, you know the difference between these species and the way they regard humans. As the saying goes, “Dogs have owners; cats have staff.”

Dogs love you no matter what. Dogs never hold a grudge. They forgive everything you do, even when you forget to feed them or let them out. Whether you’re gone for an hour or a week, they are miserable when you leave and ecstatic when you return. Dogs believe their owners can walk on water and control the heavens. A dog believes its human to be the greatest creature to ever live.

Oh, not so cats! Cats could not care less about you. They not only ignore you, they disdain you. They don’t care when you leave. They don’t care when you return. They don’t care. Period.

Every business wants their customers to adore them the way a dog adores its owner. We want all those people who get our email marketing messages to think we’re amazing. We want them waiting for our emails the way a dog waits for its owner’s return. We want to be viewed with such respect and admiration that we can do no wrong in their eyes.

But the truth is, the people we email are a lot more like cats in the way they regard us. They really don’t care. We are an annoyance when we show up in the inbox. They don’t miss us or pine for us.

If they don’t like what they’re seeing, they will tune us out faster than you can open a can of tuna. They will report an email marketer as spam only to stop getting the emails.

What does this mean? It means we work harder. The first step is recognizing that we’re dealing with cats, not dogs. As any cat owner knows, they can be won over…slowly and persistently, yet carefully. With treats and toys, affection and adoration, we can convince cats that we as human beings might just serve a purpose and have some value.

If we can convince cats, we can convince the prospects and customers getting our emails too. How? By wooing them with targeted, relevant, timely, appropriate, customer-centric email marketing. By giving them what they want, when they want it.

Make the happiness of the cats—er, customers—the focus of your email marketing program, and you will have them purring eventually.

About the Author: Marco Marini is the CEO of ClickMail Marketing and an acknowledged expert in email marketing with over a decade of experience in the field. Follow ClickMail on Twitter: @ClickMail

2 Comments
  • Page 4 of 13
  • « First
  • «
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • »
  • Last »
an indiemark blog!

Subscribe for the really good stuff!

Email
First Name
 
Follow Indiescott on the twitter
Meet the email critics.
scott hardigree
Founder of Indiemark, email marketing super guru way back since the olden days (1997), rad dude and argyle sweater connoisseur.
read more...
Scott Hardigree
scott cohen
VP of Managed Services at Inbox Group, blogger, father, and other miscellaneous stuff!
read more...
jordie van rijn
Editor at email vendor selection, email marketing consultant at Emailmonday. He actually does email all week, not only Monday.
read more...
marco marini
Marco Marini is an acknowledged expert in e-marketing with over a decade and half's-worth (yep, that's 15+ years) of experience in the field.
read more...
evan diaz
VP Creative Services at Inbox Group and all around great guy. Evan is also left handed. wow!
read more...
justin premick
Director of Education Marketing at AWeber Justin jumped into email marketing in 2004 and hasn't looked back.
read more...
home | about us | comics | hall of fame | hall of shame | resources